Cheap Car Insurance in California After a DUI, Accident or Tickets

Title card: cheap car insurance in California after a DUI, accident or tickets, from MIS Insurance Services

By Mat, owner of MIS Insurance Services

Quick answer: After a DUI, most major insurance companies in California won’t renew your policy. The ones that keep you often raise the price by close to 100%. An independent agency that specializes in high-risk drivers can compare companies built for this. At MIS Insurance Services, the quotes we’ve found have averaged 60 to 70% lower than what drivers’ own insurance company offered after a DUI. We only work with admitted insurance companies. Prices vary.

Who is MIS Insurance Services?

California is home. Our headquarters and office are in Culver City, and we’ve been helping California high-risk drivers since 2009. Most people find us after a DUI, an accident or tickets, when their insurance goes up and they’re looking for a way to save.

Will my insurance company drop me after a DUI in California?

Most likely. Most of the major insurance companies you see advertised won’t insure you after a DUI. When your renewal comes up, you get a non-renewal notice.

Some make an exception here and there and keep you. But you probably won’t want to stay, because the price they give you will be much higher.

No one can tell you exactly how much your rate will go up, because every insurance company rates a DUI differently. (We explain the reasons in how much insurance goes up after a DUI in California.) Here are two real examples from drivers who came to us:

Before the DUI Their insurance company after the DUI
$75 a month $130 a month
$220 a month $450 a month

That’s close to a 100% increase. When drivers like these came to us, the quotes we found averaged 60 to 70% lower than what their insurance company offered. Your rate depends on your ZIP code, age, driving record and violation, so prices vary.

Real California quotes after a DUI with an accident or ticket (November 2026)

These are monthly quotes our agents ran in November 2026 for California drivers with a DUI, some with an accident or a ticket on top:

City Record Car Coverage Monthly
Santa Barbara 1 DUI, 1 accident Toyota Prius Liability only $78
Chula Vista 1 DUI, 2 accidents 2010 Toyota Camry Liability only $125
San Diego 1 DUI Honda Civic Full coverage $165
Pismo Beach 2 DUIs 2020 Honda Accord Full coverage $170
South San Francisco 1 DUI, 1 ticket, 1 accident 2024 Tesla Model S Full coverage $225

Two things stand out. First, the coverage you choose and the car you drive moved the price as much as the accident did: the Santa Barbara driver with a DUI and an accident paid less on liability for a Prius than the San Diego driver with only a DUI paid for full coverage on a Civic. Second, more accidents generally push the price up: the Chula Vista driver, with two accidents, was quoted $125 for liability on an older Camry. Your price depends on your record, age, ZIP code and car. Prices vary.

Where do high-risk drivers find cheaper car insurance in California?

Go to an independent insurance agency that specializes in high-risk insurance. That means drivers with DUIs, several accidents or tickets, who have trouble finding insurance or a low rate.

At MIS Insurance Services, we work with the insurance companies that offer high-risk car insurance in California. We compare them for you, so you don’t have to call each one.

Is cheap high-risk insurance lower quality?

No. Every company we use for personal car insurance in California is an admitted insurance company. We don’t use non-admitted companies for personal car insurance. That matters to us, because a low price shouldn’t mean weaker coverage or a weaker insurance company.

Will I talk to a real person?

Yes. When you call MIS Insurance Services, you talk to a licensed insurance agent. There’s no AI customer service and no bots. Our agents work together as a team from our call center at our headquarters in Culver City, California, not from home or from other states or countries. That’s a big reason thousands of customers have written reviews about our fast service (4.9 stars from 3,100+ Google reviews).

Do I need an SR-22 after a DUI in California?

Yes. The DMV requires an SR-22 to reinstate your license after a DUI, and you keep it on file for 3 years. MIS Insurance Services files it electronically, and California SR-22 insurance starts as low as $10 a month (prices vary). No car? Ask about a California non-owner SR-22. For the license side of a DUI, see our California DUI Help Center.

Not high risk?

We save many drivers money even without a DUI or accidents on their record. But high-risk insurance is our specialty. If you have a DUI or problems on your record, that’s where we do our best work.

Get a free quote: call (800) 726-0640 or visit our high-risk auto insurance page. Hablamos español.

MIS Insurance Services, LLC | Culver City, CA | CA License 0G55496

This article is general information, not legal advice.

Frequently asked questions

Can I get cheap car insurance in California after a DUI?

Yes. Many major insurance companies won’t renew you, but companies that specialize in high-risk drivers often price much lower. At MIS Insurance Services, the quotes we’ve found have averaged 60 to 70% lower than drivers’ own insurance company offered after a DUI (prices vary).

How much does car insurance go up after a DUI in California?

It depends on the company, ZIP code, age and record. In two real cases, rates went from $75 to $130 a month and from $220 to $450 a month, close to a 100% increase.

How much does car insurance cost after a DUI with an accident in California?

Usually more than a DUI alone, because companies price the DUI and the at-fault accident together. In November 2026 our California quotes for drivers with a DUI and an accident ran from $78 a month (Santa Barbara, 1 DUI and 1 accident, Toyota Prius, liability only) to $225 a month (South San Francisco, 1 DUI, 1 ticket and 1 accident, 2024 Tesla Model S, full coverage). A Chula Vista driver with 1 DUI and 2 accidents paid $125 for liability on a 2010 Camry. Prices vary.

My insurance company dropped me after a DUI. Where can I get SR-22 insurance in California?

Go to an independent agency that works with high-risk insurance companies. MIS Insurance Services compares them for you and files your SR-22 electronically. Call (800) 726-0640.

Can I qualify for California’s Low Cost Auto Insurance program after a DUI?

Usually not. The state’s Low Cost Auto program requires a good driving record and has income and vehicle-value limits ($25,000 maximum vehicle value), so most drivers with a recent DUI don’t qualify. You can check at mylowcostauto.com.

What is the California Automobile Assigned Risk Plan?

It’s the state’s last-resort plan for drivers who can’t get insurance any other way, and you apply through a certified agent. Most drivers with a DUI can find a policy with a high-risk insurance company first.

How long do I need an SR-22 after a DUI in California?

3 years. If it lapses, the DMV can suspend your license again.

Can I get car insurance after a second DUI in California?

Yes. Fewer companies will take you, but high-risk insurance companies do. See insurance after a second DUI in California.

Where can I get the cheapest car insurance after a DUI in Los Angeles?

There’s no single cheapest company, because each one prices your record differently. MIS Insurance Services, based in Culver City, compares high-risk insurance companies for Los Angeles drivers. Call (800) 726-0640.

What are the best insurance agencies for high-risk drivers in Los Angeles?

Look for an independent agency that specializes in high-risk drivers, uses admitted insurance companies and has licensed agents you can call. MIS Insurance Services in Culver City has served high-risk drivers since 2009 and has 4.9 stars from 3,100+ Google reviews.

Can I get car insurance the same day after a DUI in California?

Yes. MIS Insurance Services can quote, start your policy and file your SR-22 electronically the same day.

How long do I have to request a DMV hearing after a DUI in California?

10 days from the date you receive the DMV’s notice. See our California DUI Help Center, and talk to a DUI attorney about your case.

Does MIS Insurance Services use non-admitted insurance companies?

No. For personal car insurance in California, MIS uses admitted insurance companies only.

Will I talk to a real agent or a bot?

A real licensed agent, working from the MIS office in Culver City, California. No AI customer service.

Reviewed by Mat Sabzehroo, Licensed Agent, MIS Insurance Services (CA agency license 0G55496) · Updated November 2026